Dr Abdul satar Doshoki Chabahari the leader of baloch2000       

Dr Waild Garboni The king of Garbon

Dear Mr Waleed Garbouni
“Gozaresh” Nevisi Baloch has reached Europe.

I read your letter published in the Balochi websites. You have many good point and some other points that I disagree , but say nothing now because other important issues. I think there is a very important and painful matter exist that you not mentioned in your letter. Please explain about this and analyse it. We knew the fight and disturbances among BPP and BUF. We have seen this very sad things published in Baloch2000 and accusation and insults every night in Paltalk against the leaders of BUF by members of BPP. I criticise and blame both Baloch2000 and BPP and Its 3 websites and the Paltalk. Although Baloch2000 does not mention any specific name. The other group ( BPP) are very open and direct in insulting individuals by name.

I think this fighting is among Baloch and not very important because Baloch knows Baloch. I am not saying it is good. It is bad; but not as bad as we start fighting openly in front of other people. An important thing happened and most Baloch did not care or could not care about it. From what I have heard on Paltalks and read in Baloch web sites, it is very sad. If BUF and BPP want to show Baloch people to other people like this, They should close both shops and we Baloch to both of them say Thank you ! Go home.

 

 As far as I know it ( learned from Paltalk, websites, and talking to some people) the issue is like this. There were some conferences in which all nationalities like kurd, arab, turkamn, va Baloch , azari , others took part. At least two parties from very nationality took part in the Cenferences. For example Komlleh is a left party and Hezb e Demokrat is moderate. Both like brothers took part and did not fight with each other. IT is the same with Azrari Turks and Arabs and Turkman and others.

Then Mr Doshoki wrote a article and criticised two Azari Turks ( one about forming a Jebhe to overthrow the Shah, the other about another Turk who had said “We are not enemy with Jomhouri Eslami, but our main enemi is Fars”. I investigated very clearly. Mr Doshoki is right, these things have been said and it is true. There are two important things: One Mr Doshoki did not say anything either by name or party name. 2- Mr Doshoki never criticised BPP or it members in that Article. 3- Although Mr Doshoki is right as far as the correctness of his allegations are concerned ( because these thing have been said) But Mr Doshoki is may not be correct or right in writing these things in public article. Although those conferences were not closed and secret conferences, but still Mr Doshoki would have been wiser not to repeat these things.

 What happened next is amazing ! absolutely amazing ! I could not believe it , but it has happened. I saw the letter ( from Mr Rahim of BPP) published in Baloch 2000. What happened is the story of Baloch misery and Baloch history. Many people may know that in the Shah time how some people go to Savak and spied against his own brother. Now in Balochistan it is the same. Some Baloch compete with each other to work for Baseej and Ettelahat and then write letters and reports (Gozaresh) against other people. Both Shah regime and Jomhouri Eslami use Baloch against other Baloch. Some Baloch write Gozaresh ( Report) to Baseej, Pasdaran, Ettelahat va Beiyt Rahbari complaining against other Baloch and asking the Regime to arrest and put in prison that person because he has done this or that. We all know these things have happened in Balochistan and still are happening in Balochistan.

What is amazing is that the same thing is happening in Europe. Baloch Intelectual and political educated are doing this thing in Europe. Wake Up ! Baloch Wake UP !.

After Mr Doshoki’s writing, nobody cared. It was not important. Nobody took too much notice. Articles like these are 1000s in many websites. Even the two Azari Turks who were refered to in the Article did not care about what Mr Doshoki had said. The Amazing thing is that suddenly the Baloch ( Baloch of BPP) became “ Kaasseh Daghtar az Aash” and wrote a letter to the other nationalities in the Congreh. I am not supporting Mr Doshoki or what he has said. But I am saying even if your own brother has made a mistake or is incorrect or even very bad, it is not your duty as a Baloch to stand against your own brother. Let others fight against him and you as a Baloch ( because of Feeling of Balochi) should defend him. When you defend your Baloch brother despite who he is, you are actually defending Balochi values and not a Baloch who may be right or wrong.

The amazing things is that others ( Kurds, Azaris, Arabs, Turkman, and etc.) did not make formal complaint against Mr Doshoki, BUT those who claim to be super-Baloch and real Baloch ( like Mr Rahim of BPP) in a true Balochi style compiled a “Gozaresh” to the Congreh and conspired against the Jebhe. Mr Doshoki’s article was not part of the Agenda, but BPP worked very hard to make it part of the Agenda. Although others were cool and indifferent about Mr Doshoki’s article. But BPP were very determined to  use this article and damage the BUF and especially Mr Doshoki. In order to destroy another Baloch, the BPP did every thing they could do, even at the expense of damaging or destroying the Congreh which they have done.

Baloch2000 published this infamous letter ( Or this SHAH-KAAR) in its web site. It was signed by Mr Rahim. Then BPP published the same letter but removed the name of a mr Rahim with BPP’s name. Nobody ever asked them why do you (as a Baloch) should make it your duty (Vaziifeh) to write Gozaresh against another Baloch irrespective of the fact that he is right or wrong. Why do you thing it is the duty of a Baloch to destroy another Baloch?

Please stop writing Gozaresh to others against Baloch people and activist.If they are wrong, let them be wrong, Don’t make it your duty to destroy another Baloch. We know that such “Gozaresh” writing runs in some or a few families in Balochistan. But we have enough of those families in Iran who write Gozaresh to Baseej and Ettelahat va . . .. Please do not repeat or copy such family business in Europe.
 

Dear Mr Waleed ! it is this kind of things which damages Baloch ( Damage has already been done) Both BUF and BPP have failed. I suggest BUF should disband and stop, because the BPP would never let it to succeed. BPP since its formation has proved that it; main reason and mission of formation is to be against BUF. Last two years have shown very clearly that BPP has a mission. In my opinion, if the Leaders of BUF are real Baloch and do not want to see such disturbing fights among Baloch, then they should step down and disband the BUF. If they have made BUF a personal party or for personal reason, then it is very sad. If they care about Baloch people, then they should Dismantle and disband the BUF, so that the BPP will not have an excuse. It is very sad because there are a lot of good people in BUF and in BPP.

Dear Mr Waleed !

My question is why a Baloch should be so determined to write “Gozaresh” against another Baloch in order to destroy him? WHY? What is behind this kind of destructive behaviour? Please analyse and explain.


Dr Haji Abdulsatar Doshoki Landani