Democracy is the truth of democracy,monarchy is not truth of democracy.

Democracy is the truth of democracy; monarchy is not truth of democracy. Monarchy is forced to be democratic as non logical within itself, where as monarchical moment is not a non logical within democracy.  Democracy can be understood in its own terms, monarchy cannot. In democracy, none of its moments acquires a meaning other than that which is appropriate to it. In monarchy, a post determines the character of the whole. The whole constitution has to take shape on this foundation. Democracy is a type of species of the constitution. Monarchy is a variety, and indeed a bad variety. Democracy is form and content. Monarchy is supposed to be only form, but it falsifies the content.

In monarchy, the whole, the people, is subsumed under one of its particular modes of existence, that of the political constitution. In democracy, the constitution itself appears as only one determination and indeed as the self-determination of the people in monarchy we have the people of the constitution, in democracy we have the constitution of the people.

Democracy is the riddle of all constitutions solved. In democracy the constitution is always based on its actual foundation, on actual man and actual people, not only in itself, according to essence, but it existence, and actuality; it is postulated as autonomous. The constitution is seen as what it is, the freely created product of man. Democracy begins with man and makes the state in to men objective; just like religion doesn’t create man but man creates religion, so the constitution does not create the people but the people create the constitution.

There is no space for monarchy in Iran, time has moved forward and the people have changed.

The people in Iran value their life with different standard, to their forefather; there is a 30-year gap in the Iranian politics with no picture of shah, and to impose one on the Iranians would be artificial. Why should the people assume democracy under a monarchial regime, when Iranian could experience real democracy in the name of democracy itself? 

Monarchies have a right to campaign to return the monarchy to Iran, this is their democratic right and no body has the right to deny them. In the mean time monarchy’s supporter have no right to bully other activist to support their policy, monarchies at present are cashing in on the brutality of mullahs. Shah and mullahs to some extent are similar, shah has a god given right by family to rule the land on behalf of the god, mullahs also have claim to rule the world to save the peoples soul. Fight between mullahs and monarchies are not for democracy and none-give authority to people. Mullahs claim that because shah didn’t uphold standard or instruction, which the god stated to shah, mullahs claims they had to interfere behalf of god.

The Persian centralist and the socialist parties treat other Iranian nations as second-class citizens. They don’t believe in a democracy without, “but” or “if”. Persian nationalist and socialist state that other Iranian nations (minorities) have no right to teach their language, culture, and heritage they believe in. They claim if minorities cultivate their culture, language and so forth, minority’s language and culture could endanger Iran’s unity. Answer to their concern is that obedience to state is self imposing, and that cannot be imposed externally. The Persian believe that it has been decided in heaven which, Persian language to be states language and no one can change that on earth. Persian believes that only they have the right to state resources.

The state of Iran misinforms its people about its history and historic events, centralist parties never raise concern that population is being a misguided; they supported mullahs whenever the interest of Persian has been challenged by minorities.

Socialist and centralist parties would not agree with simple demand, which is fundamental to democracy that demand is self-determination. As minorities nationalism we never give up hope, we makeup 49 percent of the Iranian population, we struggle for our right our full autonomy, this is our historic right and the right of our relatives which living on the other side of artificial border. We never lose. If we lost this war, we gather forces for anther war. Minorities in Iran should not give up to the bullying. Our struggle is not to change style and faces in Tehran our fight is for recognition. Our struggle for better life never stops; people live more with conflict then with the peace.  

 For mullahs and monarchies while both doctrine take authorities from god, monarchy can not survive without mullahs, they will meet some where in cross road and join force together, monarchies will ask for forgiveness, monarchy is far outdated mullahs soon join them in that regard.

M.S 

Baloch_m_s@yahoo.se